Saturday, February 8, 2025

Gratuity may be forfeited of staff who damage employer property: Delhi HC

The Delhi High Court has observed that any employer can forfeit the gratuity of an employee if the employee is terminated for any act or omission or negligence causing any damage or loss to the property belonging to the employer.

Justice Pratibha M Singh however added that such forfeiture can only be to the extent of the damage or loss caused, and not beyond that. The Court was dealing with two petitions pertaining to disputes between employee and Union Bank of India.

The Court noted that sec. 4 of the Payment of Gratuity Act prescribes that gratuity would be payable to every employee on termination of his employment if the employee has rendered continuous service for not less than five years upon superannuation, retirement, or resignation, or due to death or disablement due to accident or disease.

It also noted sec. 4(6)(a) of the Act which provides that the gratuity of an employee, whose services may have been terminated for the reasons as specified therein, can be forfeited to the extent of damage or loss so caused.

“In the present two petitions, it is worth noting that ld. Counsel for the Bank, during the course of the hearing, submitted that the Bank is not pressing the ground of forfeiture of gratuity of the employees on account of offence involving moral turpitude. Thus, insofar as the procedure to be followed for forfeiture is concerned, even if this Court does not take into consideration the judgment in Jaswant Singh Gill (supra), a mere reading of the provisions itself shows that the forfeiture can be only to the extent of the damage or loss so caused,” the Court said.

“In a banking system, there may be various factual situations which may have resulted in termination of the employee. The misconduct alleged may be at an individual level or at the level of the team, for example, for sanctioning a loan, only one employee of a bank may not be fully responsible. As per Section 4(6)(a) of the Act, the omission or negligence has to exist and forfeiture can be only to the extent of damage or loss caused to the employer,” the Court observed.

The observation was made when the Court was handling two petitions related to disputes between employee and the Union Bank of India. As per one petition, the employee had been accused of issuing loans by accommodating certain parties. In the other petition, the employee was accused of issuing loans without completing the set formalities, in violation of the Bank’s procedures. The employee had also allegedly issued high loan amounts to people whose earlier loans were either overdue or were non-performing assets. In both cases, the Bank had incurred losses.

The employer has to issue a proper notice of forfeiture to the employee. This notice has to clearly quantify the loss caused due to the conscious “omission or negligence” of the employee and the employee should be given a chance to speak and be heard.

The Court was therefore of the opinion that forfeiture of gratuity by the Bank under sec. 4(6)(a) of the Act was clearly not justifiable. However, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the cases, considering the delay in filing the claim of Employee No.1 and the factual background leading to the forfeiture in the case of Employee No.2, the Court held that interest would not be liable to be paid by the Bank for the period from the date of termination till the date of application filed by each of the employees before the Controlling Authority.

Editorial

Deloitte, PWC, EY, KPMG to Hire 1 Lakh People in India in FY25

According to estimates from top company officials and industry...

Higher EPS Pension Application Stuck: A Step-by-Step Guide to Fix

Nearly 97,640 Provident Fund (PF) members and pensioners under...

Deloitte, PwC, EY, KPMG Outpace Global Growth for India Divisions

The Indian divisions of Deloitte, PwC, EY, and KPMG...

EPS-95 Higher Pension Update: Less Than 1% Cases Settled So Far

Supreme Court Ruling and EPFO’s Higher Pension Rollout The Employees’...

Strong Job Growth and Salary Increases Expected in IT Sector

India's IT sector is on track for significant growth,...

Must Read

Govt issues guidelines for Covid-19 vaccination of the aviation community

Govt issues guidelines for Covid-19 vaccination of the aviation...

Dyninno India announces a bereavement support policy for its employees

Dyninno India, a part of the global Dyninno Group...

Pension Adalat or EPS’95 Pensioners/members & EPFO officers

Social Security Organisations, EPFO has initiated an interactive platform...

Jeff Bezos to step down as Amazon Chief Executive Officer

Jeff Bezos to step down as Amazon CEO; Andy...

Richard Lobo joins Tech Mahindra as Chief People Officer

An Indian multinational information technology services and consulting company, Tech...

Happiest Minds Technologies to hire 300 people in each next 3 quarters

Bengaluru-based software firm Happiest Minds Technologies, which has been facing...

Sacked Twitter employee asks his job status, Elon Musk laughs

The social media company based in San Francisco, Twitter CEO...

Cognizant allocates $250 million funds for global CSR initiatives

Cognizant allocates $250 million funds for global corporate social...

Related Articles

Sheenu Pradhan
Sheenu Pradhanhttps://sightsinplus.com/
Sheenu Pradhan, Editor Content, SightsIn Plus. She has over 8 years of experience in human resources. Prior to this, she has been associated with Wictor Chemicals India, Wipro, and Shakti Plas Industry.