Thursday, February 6, 2025

Karnataka HC Orders Employer Consultation for Wage Revisions

Karnataka HC has recently ruled that employers should be consulted when fixing or revising minimum wages.

This decision came after a division bench comprising Chief Justice N V Anjaria and Justice K V Aravind heard an appeal by various employers’ associations, including the Karnataka Employers Association.

The ruling overturned a single judge’s order from September 26, 2023, which had set aside a government notification issued on July 28, 2023, revising minimum wages for foundry employments.

The single judge’s decision was based on petitions filed by trade unions, including the All India Trade Union Congress (R), Karnataka State Committee, and Engineering & General Works Union.

Employers as Stakeholders: Legal Arguments

The High Court emphasized that employers are crucial stakeholders whose obligations are directly impacted by minimum wage revisions.

The court noted that excluding employers from the process would render the exercise unjust and arbitrary.

The bench stated that employers should have the opportunity to present their position before the government issues notifications regarding minimum wages.

The employers’ associations argued that they were unfairly excluded from the single judge proceedings. This was despite their prior representations to the Advisory Board.

They also highlighted that the trade unions’ demand for a living wage differs significantly from minimum wage considerations.

The employee unions countered that Sections 3 and 5 of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948, do not distinguish between fixing and revising wages.

They argued that the notification was legislative in nature and did not require a hearing.

Karnataka HC Ruling and its Implications for Employers

The High Court determined that while the notification could be considered subordinate legislation, the process leading to it involves a statutory exercise.

This exercise requires reasonable implementation.

Karnataka HC emphasized that principles of natural justice are integral to such statutory procedures.

The matter has been returned to the single judge for fresh consideration, with instructions to hear the appellants’ arguments.

The entire process must be completed within 10 weeks.

This ruling has significant implications for employers, as it ensures their voices are heard in the wage revision process.

It also highlights the importance of fair and transparent procedures in setting minimum wages.

These procedures can impact the financial health and operational efficiency of businesses.


Note: We are also on WhatsApp, LinkedIn, Google News, and YouTube. To get the latest news updates, subscribe to our channels. WhatsAppClick HereGoogle NewsClick HereYouTubeClick Here, and LinkedIn: Click Here.

Editorial

Deloitte, PWC, EY, KPMG to Hire 1 Lakh People in India in FY25

According to estimates from top company officials and industry...

Higher EPS Pension Application Stuck: A Step-by-Step Guide to Fix

Nearly 97,640 Provident Fund (PF) members and pensioners under...

Deloitte, PwC, EY, KPMG Outpace Global Growth for India Divisions

The Indian divisions of Deloitte, PwC, EY, and KPMG...

EPS-95 Higher Pension Update: Less Than 1% Cases Settled So Far

Supreme Court Ruling and EPFO’s Higher Pension Rollout The Employees’...

Strong Job Growth and Salary Increases Expected in IT Sector

India's IT sector is on track for significant growth,...

Must Read

Top 5 HR Technology Trends for 2024

Once Matt Mullenweg, CEO of Automattic said, “Technology is...

Wipro is hiring freshers, the last date to register May 22, 2022

India's IT services provider company Wipro is inviting applications...

LTIMindtree Hiring 500+ Jobs: Lateral and Entry-Level Roles

LTIMindtree, India’s sixth-largest IT services firm is actively hiring...

Silicon Valley Bank’s nearly 800 Indian employees face uncertainty

The Silicon Valley Bank collapsed recently last week. Post...

Adidas appoints a new Head- Human Resources

Adidas appoints new HR head after race row Adidas has...

Technology Priorities and Resolutions for HR Leaders for 2021

Technology Priorities and Resolutions for HR Leaders for 2021 As...

Related Articles

Sahiba Sharma
Sahiba Sharmahttps://sightsinplus.com/
Sahiba Sharma, Senior Editor - Content at SightsIn Plus